Guild Starfire Custom DC: I Waited So Long to Try a Guild
I have a book on my desk called 2,000 Guitars. It is organized A to Z by maker, and Guild alone gets four full pages. I have flipped through it more times than I can count. So I asked myself one question: if I could pull one guitar off these pages and actually play it, which one would it be? The answer was the Guild Starfire. This is my first time ever playing a Guild, and here is what the Starfire Custom DC is really like.
2,000 Guitars and One Question
My wife gave me 2,000 Guitars as a Christmas gift about 10 years ago. It is a gorgeous, well organized book, and every page makes you want something. The problem is that a photo cannot tell you how a guitar feels, how it sounds, or how it smells. So today I am picking one guitar from the book and finding out in person.
Sweetwater sent the Starfire over and sponsored this video. I had actually seen this exact guitar in person when I visited Sweetwater earlier this year. Everybody else was playing it, and I walked right past because I did not know what it was. Now I do.
A Quick History of Guild
Guild was started in New York in 1952 by Alfred Dronge, a guitarist and music teacher. I will say his name every possible way so everyone can complain in the comments. When Gibson bought Epiphone, Dronge picked up some of Epiphone's old equipment and a handful of its craftsmen.
According to the book, the Guild name was borrowed from an amplifier company in San Diego. Did they ever give it back? Because that is what borrowing means.
Guild later moved across the river to Newark Street in Hoboken, New Jersey. That is where this guitar gets its name. The Starfire Custom DC is part of Guild's Newark St. Collection, a nod to the factory where the originals were built.
The Starfire Story
On page 166 of 2,000 Guitars there is a 1960 Starfire III: a single cutaway thin hollow body with a vibrato and two white topped single coils. The book says the Starfire grew out of an earlier Guild thinline. In 1963, Guild added a twin cutaway version, which the book frames as Guild finally admitting that the ES-335 had a point.
Right below it is a 2001 Starfire IV reissue with a double cutaway and humbuckers. The guitar I have here is basically those two photos put together: the double cutaway shape from the bottom picture, with the vibrato and single coils from the top one.
"A photo cannot tell you how a guitar feels, how it sounds, how it smells."
Who Played a Starfire?
The list is a who's who of the 1960s. John Lennon had a Starfire 12 string. Dave Davies of The Kinks played one, and so did Buddy Guy. In San Francisco, Jerry Garcia, Bob Weir, Phil Lesh, and Jack Casady all played Starfires. Tom Fogerty played one in Creedence. In England, Bert Weedon had one, and Guild even gave him his own model, which is right there on the same page of the book.
Guild Starfire Custom DC Specs
| Spec | Details |
|---|---|
| Model | Guild Starfire Custom DC GVT GH, Newark St. Collection |
| Body | Semi-hollow, double cutaway, maple top and body |
| Finish | Gloss polyurethane, Nobel Stain |
| Neck | Mahogany, set neck, Vintage Soft U profile |
| Fingerboard | Ebony, 12" radius, block inlays, 22 frets |
| Scale Length | 24.75" |
| Nut | Bone, 1.6875" |
| Pickups | 2 x Guild DeArmond Dynasonic single coils |
| Controls | 2 volume, 2 tone, 3-way toggle |
| Bridge | Guild Tune-O-Matic with GVT vibrato tailpiece |
| Tuners | Grover G2 open gear |
| Hardware | Gold |
| Strings | D'Addario EXL110 (.010 to .046) |
| Case | Sold separately |
| Price | $1,299.99 USD at the time of writing |
How It Plays
The Vintage Soft U neck feels a little wide, but not huge in my hands. Combined with the ebony fingerboard and the 24.75" scale, it feels slinky and comfortable, closer to a classic semi than a Fender style neck.
The DeArmond Dynasonic Pickups
The Dynasonics are bright and tight. This is not a jazz box mud bomb. There is lots of snap and clarity, and they love clean and edge of breakup tones. They might not take high gain very well, so I tried a few different things with them in the video to see where they shine.
If you are used to humbuckers in a semi-hollow, this is a very different flavor. Think sparkle and chime rather than warmth and thickness.
The GVT Vibrato and Hardware
The GVT vibrato is gentle. It is more of a shimmer than a dive, perfect for adding a little movement to chords. Out front you get a bone nut and Grover open gear tuners, and the gold hardware looks great against the Nobel Stain finish.
Sweetwater also had it in blue, which you would think I would have picked first. I chose this one because this is the one I chose.
Who Is This Guitar For?
| Player | Good Fit? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Gretsch-curious players | Yes | Single coil sparkle in a semi-hollow body. |
| 60s rock and roots | Yes | The Starfire's history speaks for itself. |
| Clean and crunch players | Yes | Bright, tight Dynasonics with plenty of snap. |
| ES-335 shoppers | Maybe | Same idea, but a brighter single coil voice. |
| Metal and high gain | Probably not | Not my realm, though. Tell me in the comments if I am wrong. |
What I'd Keep and What I'd Change
- Bright, snappy Dynasonic single coils
- The gentle GVT vibrato
- Comfortable Vintage Soft U neck
- Ebony fingerboard and block inlays
- Nobel Stain with gold hardware
- The Starfire history and vibe
- Case sold separately
- Not the first pick for high gain
Final Verdict
I waited way too long to try a Guild. The Starfire Custom DC brings together everything that made the 60s Starfires special: a double cutaway semi-hollow body, a gentle vibrato, and bright single coils that sound nothing like the usual humbucker semi. It plays great, looks great, and has a story you can feel when you pick it up.
One down, 1,999 to go. If you had 2,000 Guitars on your desk, which guitar would you pick next? Tell me in the comments on the video.
Where to Get It
Using my Sweetwater link for anything you buy, not just this guitar, helps support the channel.
More From the Blog
#landonbaileyyt · guild · guild starfire · starfire custom dc · semi-hollow guitar · dynasonic · newark st collection · sweetwater
Affiliate Disclosure: This video was sponsored by Sweetwater. Links to Sweetwater and Thomann may be affiliate links. Landon Bailey receives compensation from affiliate programs of which he is a partner. This comes at no extra cost to you and helps support the channel and this site. Thank you!